Google Search is undergoing its most dramatic transformation since the introduction of mobile-first indexing. With AI-powered features like Search Generative Experience (SGE) and Google SGE, Bing Copilot, and AI-integrated search in ChatGPT challenging traditional search paradigms, the landscape of organic search is shifting beneath our feet. Here at Cappella Digital Marketing Solutions (CDMS) we are sharing how AI will change organic SEO, along with tips for succeeding in this new era.
The AI-Powered Search Revolution
Google’s integration of generative AI directly into search results represents a fundamental shift in how people find information online. Rather than presenting ten blue links within traditional SERPs, AI-powered search provides synthesized answers, conversational follow-ups, and contextual recommendations. For senior living providers, this means searchers get the answer to their questions quickly, but they aren’t making decisions on those answers. For example, if their question is Do Skilled Nursing Facilities (SNF) accept Long Term Care Insurance?, they will get the answer to the question but not information on what SNF to choose.
Early data suggests that AI-generated summaries appear for roughly 15-20% of searches conservatively, and this percentage is expected to increase. Within the next two to three years, we anticipate AI overviews becoming the default experience for most informational queries.
What This Means for Organic Traffic
The traditional SEO playbook focused on ranking number one for target keywords. In an AI-dominated search environment, that top ranking may appear below an AI-generated answer that pulls information from multiple sources—including your competitors. This shift will likely result in:
Decreased click-through rates for informational content: When users can get their answers directly from AI summaries, they have less reason to visit individual websites. That doesn’t mean there is no value in informational content. Being in the top AI Overviews means increased brand recognition. At CDMS, we are seeing less organic traffic but no dip in conversions. This indicates the traffic we are losing is informational searches. Expect informational blog posts and how-to content to see the steepest declines in organic traffic.
Increased value of transactional and navigational searches: Queries with commercial intent—where users are ready to purchase or engage with specific services—will remain valuable. AI can recommend options, but it can’t complete transactions or provide personalized service experiences.
Greater emphasis on brand recognition: When AI systems cite sources or recommend businesses, established brands with strong digital footprints will have significant advantages. Being mentioned in AI-generated responses becomes the new “ranking number one.”
Five Strategies to Stay Ahead
1. Embrace E-E-A-T
Google’s emphasis on Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness (E-E-A-T) will intensify as AI systems need to determine which sources deserve citation. Invest in demonstrable credentials, author bios, case studies, and third-party validation. Original research, proprietary data, and unique insights will become your most valuable SEO assets because AI models can’t generate truly novel information—they can only synthesize existing content.
2. Optimize for AI Citation
Think beyond traditional keyword optimization. Structure your content so AI systems can easily extract and attribute information. This means using clear headings, concise explanations, data citations, and schema markup. Make it effortless for AI to understand not just what your content says, but why it’s authoritative.
Consider creating content specifically designed for AI consumption: comprehensive resource pages, definitive guides, and well-structured FAQs that AI systems will want to reference.
3. Pivot Toward Conversion-Focused Content
As informational content loses traffic, double down on content that drives conversions. Product comparison pages, service descriptions, location-specific landing pages, and content supporting bottom-of-funnel searches will maintain their value. Focus on queries where human interaction, personalization, or transaction completion is essential.
4. Build a Multi-Channel Presence
SEO can no longer exist in isolation. As organic search traffic becomes less predictable, diversify your digital presence across social media, email marketing, YouTube, podcasts, and emerging platforms. When AI systems evaluate expertise and authority, they’ll consider your entire digital footprint—not just your website.
5. Monitor Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) Metrics
New measurement approaches are emerging for the AI era. Track not just rankings and traffic, but whether your brand appears in AI-generated responses, how frequently you’re cited as a source, and what context surrounds these mentions. Tools for GEO tracking – including GA4, Semrush, and Ahrefs – are still developing, but early adopters will gain crucial advantages.
The Bottom Line
Over the next five years, successful digital marketing will require adapting to a world where AI acts as an intermediary between your content and your audience. The websites that thrive will be those that provide genuine value AI can’t replicate: original research, personal experience, brand trust, and seamless user experiences that convert browsers into customers.
The future of search isn’t about gaming algorithms—it’s about becoming the kind of authoritative, trustworthy source that both AI systems and human users naturally turn to. Start building that foundation today, and you’ll be positioned to succeed regardless of how search continues to evolve. Reach out to us at info@clcliving.org if you could use some help navigating this new AI world.
Data Sources